Back to Blog

A Neighbour's Window or Balcony Overlooks Your Yard: What Civil Code Article 647 Says and What to Do

Adding a floor often ends with a new window facing someone else's drying line or bedroom. The Civil Code sets minimum distances. How to measure them in a row house, and the steps before going to court.

Emerald 70 row houses at Kingspoint, Jl. Raya Perjuangan, North Bekasi: the rules on a neighbour's window or balcony overlooking your yard

Renovation season tends to arrive with the year-end bonus. In row-house estates, the most common renovation is adding a floor, and that often ends with a big new window or balcony upstairs. The trouble starts when that window looks straight down into someone else's backyard: the drying line, the laundry corner, or a bedroom whose curtains are usually open.

Many homeowners assume there is nothing to be done, since the neighbour is building on their own land. Indonesia's Civil Code (KUHPerdata) actually has several articles written for exactly this: windows and views into another person's yard. This guide covers what those articles say, how to measure the distances in a row house, and what to do once the window is already in.

What Do Articles 647 and 648 Say?

Article 647 of the Civil Code says nobody may have a direct view into a neighbour's yard, whether the yard is enclosed or open. So an owner may not fit their house with a window, balcony, or similar feature that looks into the neighbour's yard, unless the wall it sits in is more than twenty telapak from that yard.

Article 648 covers side or angled views. For those, the limit is looser: five telapak.

"Telapak" sounds archaic, and it is. It translates the Dutch palm from the old Dutch civil code, and in the 19th-century Dutch metric system one palm equalled one decimetre. So 20 telapak is commonly read as about 2 metres, and 5 telapak as about 50 centimetres.

Direction of the viewBasisMinimum distance to the neighbour's yard
Straight into the neighbour's yardArt. 647More than 20 telapak (about 2 m)
From the side or at an angleArt. 6485 telapak (about 50 cm)
In a jointly owned boundary wallArt. 644Not allowed without the neighbour's consent

What About Walls That Touch the Neighbour's House?

In a row house, side walls almost always abut the next house or are shared with it. For a jointly owned boundary wall, Article 644 says nobody may make a window or opening in it without the neighbour's permission.

If the wall is yours alone but sits right on the boundary with someone else's yard, Article 645 only allows light openings fitted with close-set iron bars, or fixed windows that cannot be opened. The bars may be at most one telapak apart. Openings like that let light in without opening up a view, and that is the limit the article sets.

Cracks and damp in a shared boundary wall fall under different rules. We covered them in our article on shared boundary walls in row houses.

Can These Old Articles Still Be Used?

Yes. Hukumonline's legal clinic, answering a reader whose neighbour built a balcony overlooking their yard (24 June 2014), said a balcony with a direct view into a neighbour's yard is not permitted under civil law. The affected owner can sue for an unlawful act under Article 1365 of the Civil Code.

This is a civil matter, so no police officer will turn up to board over the neighbour's window. A judge looks at each case on its facts: how close the window is, what can be seen, and what harm you suffered. That is why a lawsuit should be the last step.

Steps If the New Window or Balcony Is Already Built

  1. Measure and photograph. Measure the distance from the wall holding the window to your yard boundary, then photograph the window from your yard. Note the date installation began.
  2. Talk first. Many neighbours never realise their window faces someone's drying line or bathroom. Bring cheap fixes with you: frosted or sandblasted glass, a fixed pane, louvres or breeze blocks, or a raised sill so light still comes in without the view.
  3. Ask about the building approval (PBG). Adding a floor counts as altering the building, which needs a Persetujuan Bangunan Gedung. The approved drawings usually show where the windows go. When renovations need a PBG is covered in our article on PBG for older houses.
  4. Mediate through the RT/RW or estate management. Ask for a formal meeting and record any agreement in minutes signed by both sides. Tips are in our guide to neighbour disputes in a cluster.
  5. Send a written warning. Cite Article 647 or 648, your measured distance, and the fix you are asking for, with a reasonable deadline.
  6. File a civil claim. If nothing works, an unlawful-act claim goes to the Bekasi District Court. Bring the evidence from steps 1 to 5.

Frosted glass costing a few hundred thousand rupiah is almost always cheaper than a civil trial. Put that option on the table in the first conversation, before anyone feels attacked.

If You Are the One Renovating

The same rules apply to you. Before the builder knocks through your back wall, check how far that wall is from the yard of the house behind you. If it is under roughly 2 metres, plan openings that don't give a direct view: high windows above head height, breeze blocks, frosted glass, or a skylight. The house stays bright, and you avoid a new dispute with a neighbour you will see every day.

A window already set in concrete costs far more to change than a drawing revised before work starts.

For Kingspoint Residents

Rumah Emerald 70 on Jl. Raya Perjuangan, North Bekasi, sits on a 4.5 m × 10.5 m plot and is built as a row house. Residents planning to add space or change openings upstairs can check with the Kingspoint team first about window placement, plot boundaries, and the documents to prepare before renovating.

Frequently Asked Questions

How far must a window facing a neighbour's yard be from the boundary?

Article 647 of the Civil Code says more than twenty telapak from the neighbour's yard, commonly read as about 2 metres. For side or angled views, Article 648 says five telapak, about 50 centimetres.

Can I put a window in a wall that touches my neighbour's house?

Not in a jointly owned boundary wall without the neighbour's consent (Article 644). In a wall you own that sits right on the boundary, Article 645 only allows openings with close-set iron bars or fixed windows.

What can I do if the neighbour refuses to change the window?

Mediate through the RT/RW, send a written warning, then file an unlawful-act claim under Article 1365 of the Civil Code if it stays stuck. Courts judge each case on its facts, so keep photos and distance measurements from day one.

Planning an upstairs renovation without a feud?

The Kingspoint team can help check plot boundaries and window placement on your unit before work starts.

Ask on WhatsApp

References: Indonesian Civil Code Articles 644, 645, 647, 648 and 1365; Hukumonline legal clinic, "Hak Privasi Terganggu Akibat Tetangga Membangun Balkon di Rumahnya" (24 June 2014). The telapak-to-metre conversion is the common reading, and courts decide each dispute on its facts. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Related reading on the Kingspoint Blog